Wednesday, 26 March 2014

Have Professional Reviewers Intentionally Sacked Ryse and the Fun in Gaming

I'll intentionally start from the gamers' viewpoint. Yes, I have intentions. Lately I've been asking myself if I have fun playing video games. The Witcher, a highly praised game, is the last thing I brought myself to try and then brought myself to play on and on. Till I stopped and don't know if I'll continue it. Doesn't sound like I had fun?

Well, I've beat many games that I hadn't fun playing. Beat that game, made a check mark. From Elder Scrolls to Call of Duty, yes I once brought myself to beat a Call of Duty game. Of course I try to remember when is the last time I had fun playing a game. As I recall I had fun playing many of my SNES games, my first PC game Wing Commander IV, Archimedean Dynasty, Terra Nova, Red Alert and many other RTS games of that time. I guess every gamer has a time when he likes what he's playing or should I say, like in my case, he likes the virtual worlds born in the imagination of game developers that he gets transported to.

I bought my first PC because I saw a PC gaming magazine that a classmate let me read. Oh the wonders I saw in that magazine. But when I got my shiny and expensive new PC with Pentium inside after a lot of let's say persuasion of my parents, I forgot the gaming magazines and just gamed. I chose my games based on the pretty covers and descriptions on the back. There were duds and there were shining beacons among them. After getting a game, the duds were weeded out in no time. I still regret exchanging Archimedean Dynasty for a dud that I can't remember with a classmate. Every time I went into my local game shop I was in anticipation what wonders it will bring into my life.

But then life changed, the world changed. There were more and more games, which also means more duds, one could get pirate CD copies of games and the internet was coming. My local game shop closed, did I help kill it? Through pirate CD copies and later Warez downloads I consumed more games than ever. Then came Steam and now cloud gaming, it's easier and easier to consume games. And of course I read game magazines and game reviews. I don't know if fear of giving money for duds brought this upon me, or simply me changing with the world. Fun with games was getting less and less.

It seems to me that I now read more game reviews and previews online that I game. I know almost everything about a game before I play it and it looks to me that I have formed an opinion on a game before I play it based on online reviews, previews and other information. The crowdfunding wonder Star Citizen has made a game out of releasing information about the development of its universe and I look upon it as the next big thing that will give me fun and transport me to another world. Will Chris Roberts bring my fun and sense of wonder back? Looks like many gamers are like me based on the money that Star Citizen is getting.

I also frequent gaming forums like IGN, GameSpot and NeoGAF. Do you know that GameSpot has a subforum named System Wars? It's even the most frequented one there. One would think this has to be a very successful game, System Wars sounds very similar to Star Wars, so could be a space game. But when you enter that forum you notice very fast that other systems are at war there. There fight modern gaming crusaders under the banner of gaming systems. PlayStation is killing the Xbox, and Xbox is slaughtering the PC. Nintendo they don't even take seriously anymore.

IGN is not much different and NeoGAF is more the place of the backstabby passive-aggressive diplomat type that hopes to lure the enemy over to his side with a well informed opinion.

What are the weapons of these modern crusaders, the system warriors. Metascores, game previews and technical analysis a la Digital Foundry. And of course a lot of name calling, which former Microsoft man Adam Orth can say a word or two about. The words toxicity and troll are often associated with these system war arenas. The word fun is not often used there, could it be that you can't fight with something that you don't have?

Let me now come to the professional game reviewers, and I call most of them that way because they are paid for that. Do they turn which way the wind blows? Bam, I started with the hammer.

Last year was again the launch of a new generation of consoles, and the flames of war burned hotter than ever. There was aggression, even the passive-aggressive type, there was hate. And there were victims. The victim of the last generation launch was Sony, this time it was Microsoft that made blunder after blunder and made life easier for Sony to win the PR war at launch.

The Sony win was so big that the SDF (Sony Defense Force) is still overwhelming the forums, game review comments and articles about the consoles and their games. The Xbots are on the retreat, afraid of the SDF. The SDF is full of praise of almost every move that Sony make, one could call them PSbots, religiously following their leaders like the Manson family.

And the gaming press went where the wind was blowing. You could read digital rights bla bla bla, Kinect privacy bla bla bla. Some lords of war at Microsoft had to go because of this defeat and some Xbox One games fell victim. I'm concentrating on the highest profile launch victim here, namely Ryse: Son of Rome.

The game was first presented at E3 last year, so after the shitstorm that was the unveiling of the new Xbox. And right away Ryse was labeled by the gaming press as QTE bla bla bla, repetitive bla bla bla, boring bla bla bla. Some of the gaming press chose to ignore the game or only mentioned it casually. It got the lovely nickname Ryse: Son of QTE by the SDF.

You could almost feel the fear of the SDF and some of the gaming press that went where the wind was blowing. Would Ryse get great reviews the tide of battle could turn and the gaming press would look like amateurish idiots. First and foremost Ryse's unmatched graphics and high production values made them nervous. What if a good game was hiding under that shiny surface?

Then the reviews of Ryse came in, and they were devastating. All the press were tooting in the same horn, boring with a bad combat system, repetitive, QTE, bad story, pretty but nothing to write about. The Adam Sesslers were having dissertations on how historically inaccurate it is, and so on. As often, the one black sheep was Kotaku whose reviewer dared to voice his honest opinion and write that Ryse was fun and he recommends it to gamers. He was promptly flamed by the SDF.

As the best looking console launch game, the Xbots of course used Ryse as their weapon of choice in the battle of which system is more powerful. The SDF countered violently with Killzone: Shadow Fall. A game that has higher resolution simply can't look worse than a low res launch game from the weakly Xbone. If they had to retreat from that argument, they of course countered with Metascores. Some more passive-aggressive SDF types praise Ryse for its looks but at the same time don't forget to patronizingly mention that it's still second to Killzone: Shadow Fall or inFamous: Second Son.

Just so it happened that, regardless of bad Metascore, some Xbox One gamers picked up Ryse, and surprise surprise, it was fun. Mind you, many first simply didn't dare to write fun, but used adjectives like guilty pleasure and mindless fun to not get flamed. Some admitted completing the game multiple times in contrast to some games that got glowing reviews. On the higher difficulties the game also required strategy to survive. And surprise, the combat system was more realistic than other so called hack and slash games a la God of War, and even the Dark Souls combat looks somewhat crude in execution when you compare it.

Luckily many more gamers dared not to listen to reviews and discovered that Ryse is a lot of fun. Simply poking at the Amazon game reviews you see that people have a lot of fun with the game and the game is very popular among the gamers who bought it at the Xbox One digital store. Some gamers ask themselves what were the reviewers smoking when they played Ryse, or if they even played it at all.

Seeing the tired faces of game reviewers at the consoles' launch I would say that they sure had to play a lot, the question is how much of that was Ryse. That's simply a guess, could it be that Ryse was anyways labeled as boring, repetitive, soulless since E3, so why bother if I have so much work? Why not just rehash all the labeling? Well, some of the gaming news outlets like IGN latter retracted on the harsh criticism and admitted that the game was fun. But mostly they were concerned that gamers forget Ryse and the reviews, they thought that who wants to bother with that unimportant game and we could be labeled as amateurish idiots or worse, hype followers.

One thing that is even worse to say for a professional game critic is that he lost fun playing games, or he never had it. Then they are unusable in gamers' minds, why listen to him if he does it for the money or his ego.

Should professional game critics ask themselves if they have fun gaming? Should you play video games because well it's a habit, who needs fun? Everyone has to answer these questions for himself. I know that if I want the mystery of new games to return I should stop looking for reviews, previews, yes even stop peeking at the final scores. And fun is not what I'll find in gaming forums, well sometimes it can be fun, but for the wrong reasons.


  1. When you're tired, you want to relax after a stressful working hours, you need to have time to take care of the kids active.
    Please visit our website and play exciting flash games.
    Thanks you for sharing!
    Friv 4

  2. AvriqPrinter RepairPrinter InstalltionWifi trouble shooting
    Software InstalltionNicely well-written article. It was an awesome article to read. Complete rich content and fully informative.
    Virus removal

  3. I enjoyed over read your blog post. Your blog have nice information, I got good ideas from this amazing blog. I am always searching like this type blog post. I hope I will see again.
    Touch Hypersonic Double Din Player Mirror
    J3L Touch Double Din Player
    Hypersonic Double Din Player Mirror
    J3L Double Din Player Mirror
    Hyundai Xcent OEM Double Din Player

  4. I acknowledge that not all people who enjoy playing video games have an addiction. Video games have become a part of our culture. They allow us to have a virtual life. MSI Z270 Gaming Plus review

  5. Great survey, I'm sure you're getting a great response. Gaming

  6. Thanks for share this article.
    Delta Customer Service Number
    Delta Customer Service
    Delta Customer Number
    Delta Service Number
    +18882623768 Delta customer number for
    Technical Support
    Cargo Department
    Customer Service
    Lost Baggage
    Medallion Status


    CALL 1 877 877-1481
    We Resolve : WordPress Errors, Do WordPress Maintenance,
    Provide WordPress Support, Get WordPress Hosting,
    Do WordPress Website Customization and WordPress Website Development,
    Also WordPress Installation, And WordPress Migration and much more.
    wpfixd 1 877 877-1481
    Wordpress Website Development
    Wpfixd Blog
    SEO Services




    CALL 1 877 877-1481

    Call for Immediate Assistance for any WordPress Issue and Custom Website Development.
    We Resolve : WordPress Errors,
    Do WordPress Maintenance,
    Provide WordPress Support,
    Get WordPress Hosting,
    Do WordPress Website Customization and WordPress Website Development,
    Also WordPress Installation, And WordPress Migration and much more.

  9. Quickbooks Enterprise Support Phone Number
    Get Help for all your issues with QuickBooks Enterprise.
    Call (888) 802-9333
    Call Intuit QuickBooks Online Customer Services Helpline Phone Number USA 1-888-802-9333 to fix your Accounting Issues.
    QuickBooks Technical Support Contact Team Will fixes your issue Enterprises,
    Payroll, Pro, Premier, Vat, Bank Errors etc , QuickBooks Online Support Number 1-888-802-9333 USA

  10. +1 (888) 262-3763 Delta Airlines Customer Service Number for :

    Delta Airline Reservatations

    Airline Booking

    PNR Change

    Online Delta Ticket Booking

    Delta Customer Care

    Best phone number to reach Delta

    Airline VIP Lounge

    Delta Celebrity Reservation

    24 hours, 7 days
    Delta customer service number .
    Get in touch with Delta’s customer service department through the following phone numbers,email and contact form.
    For more information about reservations, technical support, cargo department, lost baggage and medallion status, please call the numbers listed Above .

    Delta Customer Service Number

    Delta Customer Service
    Delta Customer Number
    Delta Service Number
    Delta Airlines Reservation Number

  11. I like this post because it contains a lot of useful information to read, maybe everyone will like me. I hope this post of yours will be more appreciated by it really excellent, i enjoyed it, thanks for posting it.
    jogos 360 gratis, Jogo para menina, io game online, cá koi mini


  12. coupons-me have many coupon code stores.they provide many deals and discount offers on every store.
    if you are interested so click on the given link
    promo code

  13. We are popular as Florist Service in Gurgaon from last 10 Years, we also offers fresh flowers cakes and latest gifts across Gurgaon. Send flowers online and Offline from flower shop for your loved ones and availlable for corporate gifting with fastest delivery.

    Florist Service in Gurgaon
    Online Florist Services in Gurgaon

  14. Nice post. It is really interesting. Thanks for sharing the post!
    Buy AC Online | Smart LED TV
    Laptops for Sale | Best Inverter AC

  15. Thank you so much for this wonderful Post and all the best for your future. I hope to see more post from you. Reading a lots wonderful blogs on instagram with site insta stalker

  16. I reached out t For Logo Design during a critical time when my online business, MiBakery, was just starting to take off. I was on a tight budget and couldn’t spend too much on a new logo, but I wanted something that would boost my business and differentiate it from the regular crowd. Someone recommended this website to me and that’s how I reached out to them and told them about my situation. One of their designers, Michael, was very patient and understanding and recommended me one of their logo designs packages that was affordable for me. The final logo design was delivered to me within a week and was a custom, professional logo design that was creative and well suited to my business. Thanks a lot for all your hard work, guys!
    logo design service

  17. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon! Online Games

  18. It is truly a well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so engaged in this material that I couldn’t wait reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thanks. Xbox Generator

  19. Wonderful article. Fascinating to read. I love to read such an excellent article. Thanks! It has made my task more and extra easy. Keep rocking. Fortnite

  20. You there, this is really good post here. Thanks for taking the time to post such valuable information. Quality content is what always gets the visitors coming. Flare Files